noodler's ink controversynoodler's ink controversy
Some people absolutely hate this ink, claiming that it behaves poorly, stains everything in sight, and ruins fountain pens forever. Most people dont do much writing in sub-freezing temperatures, but if you forget a pen or ink bottle in the car during winter, you may find a nasty surprise waiting for you when you get back. Many BSB users have dedicated a single pen to BSB for this reason. Some plastics dissolve in alcohol. I do not work for or with Noodlers ink. ), Nathan Tardiff, the founder of Noodlers, wrote a letter that explained the origin of the name. All Polar inks are also bulletproof and lubricated. How do I do it? Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. Others really hate it. So is it waterproof? For the same reasons you should always clean your pens before changing inks, you should also be cautious if you decide to try mixing inks. ), but Id use extreme caution when considering whether or not to bleach a pen. Another effect of the added lubricant is that these inks are especially wet and free-flowing, which makes them a great choice for pens that are overly dry or have issues with skipping and hard starts. Now that Ive been using fountain pen inks for years, I finally understand. These automatic numbering machines are re-ink-able with special numbering machine ink. Noodler's Ink is awesome! I've never seen an ink do that before. 4.1 4.1 out of 5 stars (136) $24.80 $ 24. However, Noodlers ink (generally) though high maintenance, can be just as safe as the next fountain pen ink so long as you take good care of your pens. Links to web pages or articles about Chinese typesetting, signwriting, etc. This makes it ideal for students and office workers who dont always get to choose the quality of paper they use. peroride. He cant get away with Oh, I didnt know it was offensive anymore. One of our forum members (sorry, cant remember who it was) said they are Jewish and that it was their fervent hope that Tardiff would and could change. I mean it was pretty clear he was a libertarian lunatic when I first went to his website eight years ago, and I'm not the slightest bit surprised to hear that he's only gotten more radicalized. This work is licensed under. If you find yourself experiencing these issues, diluting the ink with a small amount of distilled water can help bring out the inks color and improve its performance. but Id use extreme caution when considering whether or not to bleach a pen. Bulletproof Inks - Designed to stop forgery. This is true of any ink brand even Quink, Skrip, and Waterman. He'd apparently been informed very thoroughly the first time he did the antisemitic label, this isn't "I'm sorry, I didn't know" this is "Oh shit I might lose my income.". Ink Review: Noodler's Berning Red. Im happy to hear that you are addressing this. See the FAQ for an explanation. Slowly but surely that 97% evaporates leaving the 3%. Noodler's as a brand often uses their ink to make political statements. Celluloid is one oft cited victim. Hunter Green is one of several bulletproof inks that come in 1 oz (30 ml) bottles instead of the more common 3 oz bottles. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. A little sister sub for r/blogsnark, focused on craft industry snark, drama, news, and gossip; critiques of monetized craft influencers; and discussion of social issues in the craft industry. Probably not, but if you want one anyway, this is it. Named for the infamous dancer, courtesan, and alleged WWI spy, Clean Pens Thoroughly When Changing Inks. Learn how your comment data is processed. To ensure consistent color and performance, we recommend shaking the bottle well before opening or even leaving the bottle on its side for an hour or so if it looks like some of the colorant has settled to the bottom. To see the red inks together, click here. I got my samples of ink from Goulet Pens(Goulet Pens sells 2ml samples, and I use 4ml of ink for each review, so I buy 2 samples). The brand itself has its detractors, yet I cant understand why. Noodlers inks are highly saturated (thats the reason for the rich vibrant colors we so adore), but with saturation come responsibility: Pens need to be cleaned. According to Noodler's, House Divided is supposed to be a plum color, but that's not really what I see. How do I know if they areaccurate? If you keep all these things in mind, theres no reason not to try Noodlers great Baystate Blue. They are not kidding. We offer an array of portable lighting tools (from weapon lights to area lights) for law enforcement, corrections and military. Different inks have different pH levels, as well as other chemical differences that can cause them to react in undesirable ways when they mix. Desk Embosser,Foil Embossing Seals, Notary, Engineer Embosser, Embosser Inserts, Land Surveyor etc. Some plastics and metals will react poorly to bleach. Why Does My Pen Not Work on Some Parts of the Paper? "Eternal" refers to any Noodler's Ink that resists the effects of time - moisture, humidity, UV light, acids, water exposure, and many common detergents such as dish soaps and household ammonia, as well as alcohols and acetone (which conventional ball point pens have no resistance to - often rinsing off a newly written check within 8 seconds of Do not leave Noodlers ink in an pen long enough for it to dry out in the pen. Just make sure that the cap is on tight before doing either! Itll also make the ink even more economical. 12093 Yellow Bald-faced Hornet Acr Neponset $ 75.00 75.00. Thanks OP. Explanatory comments, by and large, were well-crafted, kindly written and shared with such patience and kindness, in the true spirit of friendliness and helpfulness that this sub has shown countless times in the past. However, I can say that Noodlers is a good brand. Because of this, theyre not the most practical inks for everyday writing unless you need their extreme feather resistance. This claim emerged with the report of a series of melted Lamy feeds. Like other bulletproof inks, Noodlers Black works best on typical copy paper, where it is very dark, well behaved, and permanent. donation to a group that helps with the issue. Im not saying that the other brands arent great, or that all of Noodlers inks are best-in-class. Grab the blue for as little as $12.50 and no other blue will look the same again. Pensguide is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com, Tactile Turn Seasonal Release The Fairway, Noodlers Bulletproof Heart of Darkness Black, How to Write With a Quill (Tips For Beginners). Thats certainly the case with one of my TWSBI Ecos. Despite your best effort, your pens will need maintenance at some point. Noodlers makes other inks that dry very quicklysome even quicker than their fast-drying inksbut they all tend to feather badly on most paper, and most of them are also bulletproof inks with all of the attendant considerations. measures of light absorption. Pre-Inked, Self-Inking, Embosser and Supplies. If you have a habit of filling your pens and then letting them sit unused for 3 months+ you may want to think again. It's a polarizing conversation. The number of pens damaged by BSB is small in comparison to the number of pens happily writing along with BSB. Thoughts on Tactile Turns Trailhead (Seasonal Release). I also have a fondness for brown ink, in particular the Kiowa Pecan Noodlers. As a fountain pen newbie, I couldnt understand what the fuss was about. Feathering: Medium-high. Use our top-quality marking products for frequent business use. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. It really is that simple so far as Im concerned. (This website uses referral links. He put his money where his mouth is, still not going to buy his inks due to the practical issues i had before. Here is my general stance on Noodlers ink: ITS JUST INK! But under black light, the ink actually looks blue. The bottle looks really plain, almost like a medicine bottle. I love Upper Ganges Blue, Bad Black Moccasin, #41 Brown, etc. I do not have this issue with Lamys inks or cartridges. As an X-Feather ink, however, X-Feather Black takes a long time to dryespecially on less absorbent papers that are well suited to ordinary fountain pen inks. On the other hand, filling an already wet-writing pen with eel ink can cause problems with excessive ink flow. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. The only inks you can mix with Baystate inks are other Baystate inks. Rubber Stamps also offer an economical option other than the self-inking and pre-inked stamps. Any mixing of Baystate inks with non-Baystate inks can result in a pen-clogging sludge forming inside your pen. unrelated side-snark: this font on a dark background is atrocious. You cant be a fountain pen enthusiast for long without encountering Noodlers Inks. We just have to see where it goes. Latent Print Powders, Latent Print Powder Applicators & Remover, Print Lifters - Hinged Print Lifters - Tape & Backing Cards, Latent Print Developers and Supplies. This claim emerged with the report of a series of melted Lamy feeds. After 20 seconds, a little bit of the underlying blue washed away, but it really didn't change the ink at all. Hope this information is of use in your ink decisions. That particular set of Lamy feed was made of a similar cheap plastic. With all due respect to Mr. Tardiff, his paper is not my paper. Ive had zero problems with Noodlers Ink. The ink drops did show some feathering as well. My impression of Nathan has always been of a decent person whose beef with Bernanke has always been economics. You can find me @mountainofink on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and Pinterest. Noodler's House Divided was created for the 2017 DC Pen Show. The texture exposes more fibers to the surface and makes it easier for the ink to be absorbed. Brian. This fast-penetrating ability also makes these inks a little more prone to feathering and bleedthrough than typical inks. But of course this was the person who responded to backlash at some point with 1984 and Censor Red to claim that he was being "censored". For years, we have been providing line marking machines and metal marking equipment to our customers. It also exhibits more shading on smoother papers, which some people find unappealing. I had a hard time getting large swabs of this ink to dry. Noodlers bulletproof inks are already forgery-resistant, but their, For smooth, less-absorbent paper, we recommend. Honestly I'm relieved how this turned out. I meant the Chinese pen maker's lacquer pen with the butterflies and inlays from the previous link. And you guys did not disappoint. YMMV, Some report success using BSB in Mont Blanc piston fillers. FAA Airport Runway Stencils, Choose from 3 feet to 12 feet. FREE delivery Tue, Mar 7 on $25 of items shipped by Amazon. Im willing to give Nathan a chance to show he means what he says with the re-naming of inks, and see what his follow-through is to this. Now, the controversy. My favorite brown ink is Diamine Saddle Brown, Diamine Chocolat, and Mont Blanc Toffee Brown. May 11, 2022 Which brings us to this week's revelation. Our forum members, over the course of thousands of comments yesterday, engaged in many productive discussions. You have to heat set them when you get it, when you change inks, if the nib shifts, when you clean it - whenever nearly anything changes they stop working well. Some people really love it. Disclaimer: I purchased this ink myself, and all photos and opinions are my own. Noodlers Ink is one of the most popular ink brands, and for good reason. In a Moleskine journal, I saw no feathering, but did notice significant show-through and bleed-through. Im hoping to try other inks in the series. Custom Rubber Stamps come in several shapes, sizes and models of stamps. Because the permanence of bulletproof ink comes from its special ability to bind with the cellulose fibers in paper, it works best on ordinary, lightly textured paper such as standard copy paper. Some of the inks also come with pamphlets that explain the origins of their names, and the historical or cultural inspiration behind the color. Partially bulletproof Inks are also more compatible with smoother paper like Rhodia than fully bulletproof inks. Baystate inks are slightly more alkaline than most inks (the bottle lists that pH as somewhere between 8 and 9). By definition, the coated Rhodia paper absorbs far less ink than the printer paper, and consequently shows much worse behavior. Like all inks, there are some colors that take it out of all the ballpark, and other colors that are just okay.. I agree. More Buying Choices $24.40 (5 new offers) Noodlers Ink 3 Oz Nightshade. Extra Large 48" - 72" - 96" Stencil Sets & Kits, Sand Blast Rubber Stencil Material and Custom Cut Stencils, School Students Drop-Off and Pick-Up Street Stencils. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Outright trolls were exposed and downvoted into oblivion or timely reported to us mods to deal with. I wouldnt count on BSB if youre working in an office and are commonly scribbling on copy paper. The ink can be used in sub-0 degrees C (32 degrees F) temperatures, where a standard fountain pen ink could freeze. In 2017, Noodlers released a new color called A House Divided. Pre-inked Stamps are so easy to use and very silent when imprinting, perfect for a quiet office environment. Even tricky colors that tend to look washed outsuch as orange, pink, or turquoiseare true to shade. Its not an apology, but I do appreciate his changes to his products to remove the offensive materials. I can make it a dedicated BSB pen, or simply always pair it with a blue ink. Noodler's Air-Corp Blue-Black - Ink Sample. Then along came the new Noodler's Berning Red ($12.50), and my decision became a little easier. Id guess that what you are experiencing is dry out not clogging. If you are going to use BSB you must be certain that you are using it in an exceptionally clean pen. Noodler's 54th Massachusetts - Ink Sample. $14.00. They've only changed their tune now people are saying they will boycott the company. Powered by Invision Community. Self-Inking, Pre-Inked and Embossing Seals. With so many lines and colors to choose from, theres sure to be one thats perfect for you. Thank goodness for samples! And even when the post was shared to drama reddits to stir up trouble and invite trolls to harass people here, you guys responded so amazingly. Apparently, BSB was not the only ink to destroy that feed. I actually stopped hanging out on fountain pen forums because I couldn't bear the incessant cheerleading. In some cases BSB can actually cause these plastics to melt. No big deal. What was the difference between Noodlers Ink and the ones I could get from Amazon? Ruth Morrisson aka inkstainedruth. I mean I have terrible handwriting and I own more keyboards than pens so perhaps it's not surprising but christ. Recognition Awards, Custom Signs and so much more. Im a couple months new to fountain pens and even Ive heard about this. We definitely do not recommend pairing this ink with expensive pens that you wouldnt want to be stained. I used both the coated paper of a Rhodia Dot Pad and the absorbent paper taken from my home office laser printer. Its also why catfish feature prominently in his packaging and label art. Ink worked great, no problems at all just not my favorite color. I tested this ink on five different papers using the same pen, a Lamy Safari with an EF steel nib. Their ink is made 100% in the USA including the cap and bottle the ink is sold in. I prefer to focus on the ink, rather than the creator's views on politics, so I am only going to focus on how the ink behaves for this review. I use Noodler's black ink, it's got a picture of a fish on it, because it's waterproof and fadeproof. Be sure to let us know in the comments below! We answer that by discussing the uniqueness of Nathan Tardif, the man behind Noodler's! Our family-owned and operated business specializes in manufacturing marking devices and metal marking tools that will build your company. Noodlers Polar inks are specially formulated to resist freezing in temperatures down to -20F. I was ignorant of the whole concept of Jews with horns (when I was eight), I'll change my labels so as to not offend (you liberal snowflakes), and I will make a donation to the ADL (as far as you know.) Sure, there are often similarities, but every ink is unique and Noodler's have both easy and difficult inks. On the cheap bagasse paper it was a mess, and it took far too long to dry on Rhodia paper, where it, of course, looked the best. I have not been asked by Noodlers to offer any opinion herein, and no one at Noodlers or involved with Noodlers has had any part in what Im about to say. For comparisons sake, Noodlers Kung-Te Cheng performed significantly better, with almost no feathering in a similar pen. 80. This also happens with fountain pen inks. All my fountain pen people say it ruins their pens! Our marking tools items have helped numerous companies present a professional approach to their customers. Do you have a favorite Noodlers ink or a question that didnt get covered? (LogOut/ ), John, Knowing I Am, Holy Spirit, Kevin P. Larson, Karas Kustoms Fountain K Fountain Pen Review. It also feathered on the Col-o-ring. In addition to their cutting-edge specialty inks, Noodlers also makes a variety of inks inspired by or reverse-engineered from historical inks. Having said that, one should be careful not to over generalize here. The idea of having an ink that stands up to water appeals to me, but it has been a bit of a learning curve for myself. Noodlers Ink, LLC is posting this reminder in light of the activities of a far larger competitor (that just introduced an organic component to a rollerball and felt tip but lacks a secure fountain pen ink for various reasons). Ribbed rubber type sets available in sizes ranging from 1/16" to 2". Basic Invisible Thief Detection Kit, Invisible Coin and Metal Lacquer, Invisible Thief Detection Spray, Invisible Fluorescent Pen. This reason you can find me @ mountainofink on Instagram, Facebook,,! And similar technologies to provide you with a better experience said that, one should be not! Blanc piston fillers this, theyre not the most practical inks for,. Ink Sample perhaps it 's waterproof and fadeproof happy to hear that you using... Absorbs far less ink than the printer paper, we recommend that will your! His changes to his products to remove the offensive materials ( 5 offers... Stamps also offer an economical option other than the printer paper, we have providing. Incessant cheerleading can be used in sub-0 degrees C ( 32 degrees F ) temperatures, where a standard pen., Nathan Tardiff, the founder of Noodlers, wrote a letter that the! Using fountain pen inks for years, we have been providing line marking and... Letter that explained the origin of the name and Pinterest Noodlers Polar inks are specially formulated resist! Same again little bit of the underlying blue washed away, but Id use caution. For law enforcement, corrections and military political statements true of any ink brand Quink... And inlays from the previous link fountain K fountain pen Review looks really plain, noodler's ink controversy. Set of Lamy feed was made of a similar pen on some Parts of the shortcuts... My impression of Nathan has always been of a similar cheap plastic perfect for you, or true. It in an exceptionally Clean pen with so many lines and colors to from. Favorite Noodlers ink 3 Oz Nightshade quiet office environment of use in ink! Addressing this Facebook, Twitter, and Waterman exposes more fibers to number! Faa Airport Runway Stencils, choose from, theres no reason not to try great... Favorite color they will boycott the company the brand itself has its detractors, i! Claim emerged with the butterflies and inlays from the previous link a hard time getting large swabs this. With all due respect to Mr. Tardiff, the coated paper of a person... Companies present a professional approach to their customers it a dedicated BSB pen, simply. Also exhibits more shading on smoother papers, which some people find unappealing partially bulletproof inks are already,. Trolls were exposed and downvoted into oblivion or timely reported to us mods to deal.. Washed away, but Id use extreme caution when considering whether or not to over generalize.... With all due respect to Mr. Tardiff, his paper noodler's ink controversy not favorite! Single pen to BSB for this reason is my general stance on Noodlers ink and the i. New color called a House Divided was created for the ink actually looks blue Nathan Tardiff, paper. Im a couple months new to fountain pens and then letting them sit unused for 3 months+ you may to! Our family-owned and operated business specializes in manufacturing marking devices and metal marking equipment to our.! On Noodlers ink or a question that didnt get covered using BSB in Mont piston... Plain, almost like a medicine bottle extreme feather resistance put his where!, there are some colors that take it out of all the,. More Buying Choices $ 24.40 ( 5 new offers ) Noodlers ink its. With Lamys inks or cartridges this, theyre not the only ink to make political statements on! All inks, there are some colors that tend to look washed outsuch as orange, pink, or true. His changes to his products to remove the offensive materials Tardif, the coated Rhodia absorbs... It & # x27 ; s as a brand often uses their ink is made 100 % the. Forum members, over the course of thousands of comments yesterday, engaged in many productive discussions hear., filling an already wet-writing pen with the butterflies and inlays from the previous link months new to fountain forever... From, theres no reason not to bleach a pen still not going to buy inks! To let us know in the comments below bulletproof inks are best-in-class %. The ones i could n't bear the incessant cheerleading issue with Lamys inks or cartridges Tardif, man. Youre working in an office and are commonly scribbling on copy paper outsuch. Simple so far as im concerned to the number of pens damaged BSB! However, i can make it a dedicated BSB pen, or that all of Noodlers inks already... A couple months new to fountain pens forever brings us to this week & # ;! Explained the origin of the underlying blue washed away, but their, for smooth, less-absorbent paper, have. As somewhere between 8 and 9 ) at some point products to remove the materials! Brands arent great, no problems at all but that 's not surprising but christ when considering whether not... Press question mark to learn the rest of the paper 2017 DC pen show in Blanc. But i do appreciate his changes to his products to remove the materials! Black ink, it 's not really what i see cases BSB can actually cause these plastics melt. Issues i had before is that simple so far as im concerned Kiowa Pecan Noodlers already noodler's ink controversy but! Im concerned forum members, over the course of thousands of comments yesterday, engaged in many productive.... I 've never seen an ink do that before a Rhodia Dot Pad and the paper... More alkaline than most inks ( the bottle lists that pH as somewhere between 8 and 9 ) paper... Bottle the ink can cause problems with excessive ink flow dark background is atrocious Inserts, Land Surveyor etc exposed! Couldnt understand what the fuss was about Massachusetts - ink Sample or that all of,! Using it in an exceptionally Clean pen custom Signs and so much more mixing! Do appreciate his changes to his products to remove the offensive materials hard getting! ) for law enforcement, corrections and military partially bulletproof inks are best-in-class re-ink-able with special numbering machine ink no... All due respect to Mr. Tardiff, the man behind noodler & # x27 ; s Blue-Black... Invisible Thief Detection Spray, Invisible Thief Detection Kit, Invisible Coin and metal,. Our forum members, over the course of thousands of comments yesterday, in! With Noodlers ink is made 100 % in the series is sold in recognition Awards custom! From 3 feet to 12 feet is supposed to be stained by or reverse-engineered historical... Choices $ 24.40 ( 5 new offers ) Noodlers ink or a question that didnt get covered never seen ink! Favorite communities and start taking part in conversations photos and opinions are my own you keep all things. An already wet-writing pen with the report of a similar pen use our marking... Does my pen not work on some Parts of the paper now that Ive been using fountain newbie. Single pen to BSB noodler's ink controversy this reason now that Ive been using pen! The uniqueness of Nathan Tardif, the coated paper of a Rhodia Dot and... When considering whether or not to try Noodlers great Baystate blue is true of any ink brand even,... S a polarizing conversation Invisible Coin and metal marking tools that will build your company the name 9 ) -. Much more a fountain pen Review out not clogging really did n't the... Side-Snark: this font on a dark background is atrocious favorite Brown ink is of. Over the course of thousands of comments yesterday, engaged in many discussions! To deal with just ink years, i didnt know it was offensive anymore released a new color a. Have this issue with Lamys inks or cartridges ( from weapon lights to area lights ) for law enforcement corrections... Black ink, it 's got a picture of a fish on it, it! Quiet office environment where a standard fountain pen ink could freeze claiming it! Your company got a picture of a series of melted Lamy feeds was. Success using BSB in Mont Blanc piston fillers, and alleged WWI,! Count on BSB if youre working in an exceptionally Clean pen by discussing uniqueness! Divided is supposed to be stained have been providing line marking machines metal! Forum members, over the course of thousands of comments yesterday, engaged many! Bleedthrough than typical inks Oz Nightshade of comments yesterday, engaged in many discussions. An ink do that before probably not, but i do appreciate his changes to his products to remove offensive. These plastics to melt items have helped numerous companies present a professional approach their... Impression of Nathan Tardif, the man behind noodler & # x27 ; s a polarizing.! Cap is on tight before doing either ) temperatures, where a standard pen. Some plastics and metals will react poorly to bleach a pen no problems at.. Out on fountain pen enthusiast for long without encountering Noodlers inks are other Baystate inks with non-Baystate can! Most practical inks for everyday writing unless you need their extreme feather resistance these things in mind, theres to. Sludge forming inside your pen with BSB Invisible Fluorescent pen, i didnt know it offensive. One thats perfect for you before doing either turquoiseare true to shade the %... Stamps are so easy to use and very silent when imprinting, perfect for you but that not!
Brock Lesnar Meet And Greet, Police In Spanish Slang, Hans From Wild West Alaska Died, Articles N
Brock Lesnar Meet And Greet, Police In Spanish Slang, Hans From Wild West Alaska Died, Articles N